Frequently Asked Questions

Guidelines for Citing BEA Information | ID: 512 | Created: Mar-13-2009

Have there been large revisions to the personal saving rate?

As with most of its estimates, BEA revises the estimates of the personal saving rate -- personal saving as a percentage of disposable personal income -- over time. These revisions have resulted from the incorporation of new or revised source data that were not available at the time of the earlier estimates and the incorporation of improved concepts and estimation methods. Nevertheless, the revised estimates have consistently retained the long-term downward trend in the personal saving rate from the early 1980s to the early 2000s that was present in the previously published estimates (see chart).

BEA estimates personal saving as the difference between current-dollar disposable personal income and personal outlays. Revisions to the estimates of disposable personal income or of personal outlays result in revisions to the estimates of personal saving and the personal saving rate. For each quarter, BEA's revision cycle begins with three "current" consecutive quarterly estimates based on progressively more complete source data. In addition, when the second quarterly estimate -- the "preliminary" estimate -- is released for the subsequent quarter, BEA revises its estimates of private wages and salaries to incorporate newly available tabulations from the Bureau of Labor Statistics quarterly census of employment and wages.

The quarterly estimates are subject to annual revisions that encompass the 3 most recent years and that reflect newly available source data, such as annual economic surveys and tabulations of income tax data for corporations, partnerships, and sole proprietorships. About every 5 years, "comprehensive" or "benchmark" revisions implement major methodological and conceptual improvements to BEA's measures. The comprehensive revisions also incorporate the benchmark input-output accounts, which provide levels of the components of GDP for the benchmark year.

As the chart shows, successive annual and comprehensive revisions have generally (but not always) led to higher estimates of the level of the personal saving rate in the 1970s, 1980s, and 1990s, but the trend has consistently been down. Some of these revisions resulted from the routine incorporation of new or revised source data. Some of the revisions were due to methodological changes that were designed to improve the estimates, including the incorporation of revised estimates of income misreporting, which raised personal income and personal saving in the 1985 and 1991 comprehensive revisions. Some of the revisions were due to conceptual changes in BEA's measures: the upward revision to the personal saving rate in the 1999 comprehensive revision, for example, mainly reflected the a revised treatment of government employee retirement plans that made their treatment similar to private pension plans and raised personal income and personal saving. On the other hand, the 2003 comprehensive revision reduced personal saving in the 1990s, mainly because the incorporation of improved estimation methods and source data for measuring consumer spending on services resulted in upward revisions to personal outlays.

The best way to examine trends in the personal saving rate is to use consistent measures of disposable personal income and personal saving from the best available estimates produced by each revision. The initial current estimates of the saving rate are not comparable over time because they reflect inconsistent definitions and methods. As the chart shows (in which each line utilizes a consistent measure), the downtrend in the personal saving rate since the early 1990s is similar to the downward trend in the previously published estimates.

Personal saving rate

Ask us a question...

"Have there been large revisions to the personal saving rate?"
Your email address
Your question
What is 7 + 4? (Spam protection)

Double check that email address! | We won't be able to contact you if it is incorrect.

Why the math question? | This helps stop malicious programs from using this site to generate SPAM email.

Please allow us some time | It could take up to two(2) business days for our Subject Matter Experts to follow up with an appropriate answer to your question(s). Your patience is very much appreciated.

Need Help?

Using the FAQ database | All FAQs are displayed when first visiting the page. They are ordered by most recent or recently updated and can be filtered by keyword search term, by category, and by manually selecting the page number buttons. To view any FAQ, click on the title to open the answer. Submitting a question is done by selecting the “Ask a question” tab along the top of the FAQ.

Selecting an FAQ | Clicking on the title of the FAQ will bring up the answer to the FAQ. Navigating back to the list of FAQs is done by selecting the tab “Latest FAQs”. A tab to ask a question specifically about this FAQ can be found at the top of the answer. Also, the FAQ id and date this FAQ was created or last modified is shown in the upper right hand corner.

Searching the FAQs | Enter a keyword search term and click the Search button to narrow FAQ selections. To return to all FAQs, click the Clear button or clear the keyword search field and click the Search button.

Filtering FAQs by category | Chose the category to filter by and click Apply button. This will display only the FAQs related to an assigned category. To return to all FAQs click the Clear button next to the search by keyword field or select ALL from the drop down menu and click Apply button.