Containing Consumption Zones PDF
Researchers at the U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis recently introduced a new economic-geographic unit, the consumption zone (ConZ), to characterize the geography of consumption, much as commuting zones (CZs) are used to delineate labor markets. In this paper, we revisit ConZs using more recent Mastercard transaction data in the USA and revise the hierarchical clustering algorithm applied in prior work to more closely align with the methodology originally developed for CZs. We also introduce a new containment-based stopping rule that determines the number of clusters based on the share of economic activity occurring within each zone, which provides a stopping criteria that is both easily understood and economically meaningful. Setting a baseline containment level of 80%, we obtain consumption zones that differ substantially from earlier estimates and that vary markedly across industries, underscoring how the geography of consumption depends on the sector studied. For nonlocal services where consumer travel is common, such as accommodations, performing arts, and other recreational activities, we report alternative nonlocal consumption zones constructed at a 50% containment threshold, which yields more useful clusters for these industries. Overall, we view these zones as preferable to prior estimates because they follow the original algorithm of CZs more precisely and apply more transparent and meaningful stopping rule.
JEL Code(s) R12 P23 Published